The
Notorious
FIG
Winner of the World Champion Pizza Challenge
We call it Stashmosphere…
Come taste for yourself why we have been voted Best Pizza in Crested Butte every year since 2002 when we opened!
We’re glad you’ve made it to Crested Butte and found The Secret Stash. Good job! Now that you’re here, kick back, relax & chill.
You are far away from the hustle and bustle of fast food America. Dining at the Stash is an experience for all the senses, one to be enjoyed to the fullest.
We’re not trying to get you in and out as quickly as possible. We’re trying to create a truly memorable dining experience for you, one that stays with you forever.
Who We Are
Kyleena Falzone
Ky grew up in Williamsville, New York. At age 19 she traveled to Italy to meet her relatives, who own a restaurant in Sicily. That’s when the notion of owning her own restaurant came about. After graduating from the university of Buffalo, Kyleena grabbed a backpack and over the course of the next eight years, traveled to more than 62 countries. She eventually returned and ended up in Vail, where she set about learning everything she could about running a restaurant. Spending winters in Vail, working at Sweet Basil & The Game Creek Club and summers in the Hamptons, New York working at Pino Luango’s Sapore Di Mare, and Gar Wood’s in Lake Tahoe, California, she felt she had acquired the knowledge she needed to open her own restaurant.
Carson West
Carson, the true definition of a “Renaissance Man”, this guy does it all. Born and raised in the Sierra Foothills of California, Carson completed his university degree while living in Santa Cruz, California, and then landed in Crested Butte. Here, he has honed his skills in creative restaurant design, build, and management, all while living the life of an outdoor enthusiast. With a constant drive to “crush it”, look for Carson in all facets of restaurant operations as well as on the bike trails and winter slopes.
Training starts early around here.
Teaching Willa to make Secret Stash Pizza 🍕
Secret Stash Pizza Open Everyday 11am-9pm. Dine In, Take Out and Delivery Starting at 4pm.
Please bring back the New Potato Caboose!
The transformation of the Original Secret Stash Pizza in Crested Butte Colorado from restaurant to a beautiful cozy home.
I miss the original Secret Stash. Nice job on the home remodel though.
Way out of my price range, but it's darling! Love how it turned out!
No, that's not your original building
Love love love ❤️
Robert Kelly
Brandi Edwards Hurst
Brooke Ann Lisa Danelle Lucas Matt Collins
I love this pizza!!!!!!
Secret
Stash
Wings
Voted Best Wings in Crested Butte Since 2002
The
Booty
Call
Meat and Cheese, Meat and Cheese, and MORE Meat and Cheese…
Seriously!
Appetizers
Crack Fries
Fries tossed in parmesan, white truffle oil & cracked black pepper.
Stash Wings
VOTED CB’S BEST WINGS. Grilled with our house made bbq sauce, toasted sesame seeds & green onions.
Buffalo Wings
Our take on the original served medium spice. Hot as you like upon request.
Garlic Bread
Stash garlic butter on a baguette with a side of marinara. Add Cheese for $1. Add Garlic Bread to any order of Pasta for just $2.
Meat Candy
Grilled pork shanks, dry spice rub, carolina style sauce, pineapple slaw.
Mozzarella Stix
Served with pesto marinara.
Salads
Rupee
Spring greens, fresh veggies, dried cranberries, toasted pumpkin seeds & Dijon vinaigrette.
Liza’s Roughage
Spring greens, tomatoes, carrots, red onion, cucumbers grilled chicken, hard cooked eggs, pasta, sunflower seeds, creamy garlic parm dressing & croutons.
Our Pizzas
Mac Daddy
Thousand island dressing, mozzarella, shaved ribeye, onions, american & cheddar cheese, topped with cool lettuce, pickles, on a sesame seed crust (locals favorite).
Asher’s Pie
BBQ & chipotle base, cheddar & mozzarella cheese, canadian bacon & grilled chicken.
Spicy Wais
Traditional sauce, sriracha swirl, mozzarella cheese, pepperoni, chopped garlic, cilantro, tomato & fresh jalapeños.
Notorious F.I.G.
Winner of the World Champion Pizza Challenge: Mozzarella, bleu & asiago cheeses, thinly sliced prosciutto, dried black mission figs & a drizzle of truffle oil.
The Hamptons
Olive oil base, mozzarella, prosciutto, lemon pepper crust, garnished with arugula, shaved parmesan & a lemon crown.
Gertrude’s Veggie Delight
Traditional sauce, mozzarella, asiago, basil, tomato, bell peppers, mushrooms & onions.
You’re Driving Me Caprese
Olive oil base, Fresh mozzarella, slices of the biggest tomatoes we can find, salt & pepper crust with fresh basil, garnished with pickled red onions & balsamic reduction.
Booty Call
Meat & cheese & then more meat & more cheese & then more meat & more cheese and more meat… seriously.
Meatball Pie
Traditional sauce, meatballs, roasted garlic, white onions, mushrooms, mozzarella, asiago & provolone cheese & a little extra sauce.
Woodward
Garlic butter base, spinach, prosciutto, mozzarella & provolone, salt & pepper crust. Topped with fresh eggs over easy.
Texas Bigg’n
Traditional sauce, mozzarella, pepperoni, sausage, Canadian bacon, onions, bell peppers, mushrooms & black olives.
Where’s The Beef
Olive oil base, light mozzarella, minced garlic, red onions, mushrooms, black figs, asiago cheese, fresh basil, topped with balsamic reduction & truffle oil.
Kids Pasta
Kids Pasta – Butter
Bowtie farfalle pasta with butter.
Kids Pasta – Marinara
Bowtie farfalle pasta with marinara.
Kids Pasta – Marinara & Meatball
Bowtie farfalle pasta with marinara and meatballs.
Kids Pasta – Chicken & Broccoli
Bowtie farfalle pasta with creamy cheesy chicken and broccoli.
Take
Out
&
Delivery
Available
The
Mac
Daddy
Because YES!
Lettuce and Pickles on Pizza is
AMAZING!
Order Food, Merch & Gift Cards Online!
The
Hamptons
Arugula, Prosciutto, Parmesan, Lemon =
YUM!
Events at the Secret Stash
Crested Butte’s Hottest New Party & Event Venue
WEDDING RECEPTIONS
REHEARSAL DINNERS
HOLIDAY PARTIES
BIRTHDAY CELEBRATIONS
AND MUCH MORE
Our unique pizzas, pastas and drinks are always a hit!
Customize your gathering with a theme or let us decorate to enhance your experience in our already eclectic interior.
Enjoy our new space while playing pool, lounging around the fire place, playing games, and sipping your favorite after dinner liqueur.
We look forward to entertaining you!
*Note – Unfortunately The Secret Stash does NOT take reservations of any kind. We do however want you to to have a blast and enjoy the Secret Stash. Please come in and see our host and they we will do everything humanly possible to get you seated as quickly as possible (we have been known to build tables and get creative to make it work!). This event booking section is for large private parties that require a complete restaurant buyout (May not be available during Peak Season.)
Contact Stephanie or Laura to coordinate your fabulous Crested Butte event:
Laura Silva
I have been a local CB resident for over 18 years and involved with party planning in Crested Butte for over 10 years. I have been the premier local DJ in the Gunnison Valley and always create an environment that allows the client to relax and enjoy all the details of their special event.
Stephanie Prater
I have traveled the world shooting catalogs, producing weddings, designing and styling properties and creating stress free production for the last 25 years. Allow me to create the perfect gathering for you at the Secret Stash. The possibilities are endless. I look forward to working with you!
You’re
Driving Me
Caprese
Love caprese salad?
You’ll love this pizza!
Contact Us
*Note – Unfortunately The Secret Stash does NOT take reservations of any kind. We do however want you to to have a blast and enjoy the Secret Stash. Please come in and see our host and they we will do everything humanly possible to get you seated as quickly as possible (we have been known to build tables and get creative to make it work!). Please do not contact us asking for a reservation unless you are a large private party that requires a complete restaurant buyout (Even full buyouts may not be available during peak season.)
